A missing iterator on itertools module?

Mark Bourne nntp.mbourne at spamgourmet.com
Fri Mar 29 07:27:20 EDT 2024


Stefan Ram wrote:
> ast <none at none.fr> wrote or quoted:
>> Why did you renamed itertools as _itertools ?
> 
>    Assume I have a module A.py:
> 
> import math
> def f(): pass
> 
>    . Assume I have an additional module B.py:
> 
> import A
> 
>    . Now, when I'm editing "B.py" in IDLE and type "A.", IIRC
>    IDLE will offer me two possible completions: "A.math" and
>    "A.f". The "A.math" makes no sense to me.

`import math` imports the `math` module and binds it to `math` in the 
global namespace of the `A` module.  Since it doesn't have a leading 
underscore, by default it's considered to be a public attribute of the 
`A` module, and IDLE is offering all the public attributes of the `A` 
module for completion.

> I want it to go
>    away. Therefore, I rewrite A.py as:
> 
> import math as _math
> def f(): pass
> 
>    . Now, Idle will only offer the completion "A.f".
> 
>    So, I sometimes use this "import math as _math" style. But then,
>    it is simpler for me to /always/ use this style; after all: you
>    can't know whether someone eventually will import your module!

You can explicitly declare the public interface of a module by defining 
`__all__`, listing the names which should be considered part of the 
module's public interface; see:
- https://docs.python.org/3/reference/simple_stmts.html#the-import-statement
- https://peps.python.org/pep-0008/#public-and-internal-interfaces

Although `from A import *` is generally discouraged, if `A` defines 
`__all__` then only the names listed in `__all__` are bound in the 
importing module's namespace.  Otherwise, all names from `A` which don't 
have a leading underscore are considered to be public and bound in the 
importing module.

I don't use IDLE, but it may be that it also uses `__all__` to determine 
a module's public API.  In that case, setting `__all__ = ["f"]` in `A` 
should prevent it from offering `math` as a completion (nor any other 
name that's not in the `__all__` list).

-- 
Mark.


More information about the Python-list mailing list