[Python-Dev] Rounding float to int directly (Re: struct module and coercing floats to integers)

[Greg Ewing]

M.-A. Lemburg wrote:

> Believe me: you have to if you want to do more
> advanced calculus related to pricing and risk
> analysis of derivatives.

When you do things like that, you're treating
money as though it were a continuous quantity.
This is an approximation, so you can tolerate
having small inaccuracies in the result.

But when adding up actual, real amounts of
money, where the result must be exact, using
binary fractions is a very bad idea.

> This is not the same: if you round both value
> and then compare, you test a different interval
> than by taking the difference and applying
> a tolerance value comparison:

That's exactly my point. Chopping decimal
places is not a substitute for doing tolerance
testing properly.

> Most typical uses of round() don't use the
> optional argument, true, but I still fail
> to see what returning an integer instead of
> a float would buy you.

It saves you a function call in the vast
majority of cases, where an int is what
you ultimately want.

--
Greg