[Python-checkins] python/nondist/peps pep-0304.txt,NONE,1.1

[montanaro@users.sourceforge.net]

Update of /cvsroot/python/python/nondist/peps
In directory sc8-pr-cvs1:/tmp/cvs-serv23990

Added Files:
	pep-0304.txt 
Log Message:
new pep - initial feedback from python-dev incorporated.


--- NEW FILE: pep-0304.txt ---
PEP: 304
Title: Controlling generation of bytecode files
Version: $Revision: 1.1 $
Last-Modified: $Date: 2003/01/23 17:26:42 $
Author: Skip Montanaro
Status: Active
Type: Draft
Content-Type: text/x-rst
Created: 22-Jan-2003
Post-History: 


Abstract
========

This PEP outlines a mechanism for controlling the generation and
location of compiled Python bytecode files.  This idea originally
arose as a patch request [1]_ and evolved into a discussion thread on
the python-dev mailing list [2]_.  The introduction of an environment
variable will allow people installing Python or Python-based
third-party packages to control whether or not bytecode files
should be generated, and if so, where they should be written.


Proposal
========

Add a new environment variable, PYTHONBYTECODEBASE, to the mix of
environment variables which Python understands.  Its interpretation
is:

- If not present Python bytecode is generated in exactly the same way
  as is currently done.  sys.pythonbytecodebase is set to the root
  directory (either / on Unix or the root directory of the startup
  drive -- typically ``C:\`` -- on Windows).

- If present and it refers to an existing directory,
  sys.pythonbytecodebase is set to that directory and bytecode files
  are written into a directory structure rooted at that location.

- If present but empty, sys.pythonbytecodebase is set to None and
  generation of bytecode files is suppressed altogether.

- If present and it does not refer to an existing directory, a warning
  is displayed, sys.pythonbytecodebase is set to None and generation
  of bytecode files is suppressed altogether.

After startup, all runtime references are to sys.pythonbytecodebase,
not the PYTHONBYTECODEBASE enbironment variable.  sys.path is not
modified.


Glossary
--------

- "bytecode base" refers to the current setting of
  sys.pythonbytecodebase.

- "augmented directory" refers to the directory formed from the
  bytecode base and the directory name of the source file.

- PYTHONBYTECODEBASE refers to the environment variable when necessary
  to distinguish it from "bytecode base".

Locating bytecode files
-----------------------

When the interpreter is searching for a module, it will use sys.path
as usual.  However, when a possible bytecode file is considered, an
extra probe for a bytecode file may be made.  First, a check is made
for the bytecode file using the directory in sys.path which holds the
source file (the current behavior).  If a valid bytecode file is not
found there (either one does not exist or exists but is out-of-date)
and the bytecode base is not None, a second probe is made using the
directory in sys.path prefixed appropriately by the bytecode base.

Writing bytecode files
----------------------

When the bytecode base is not None, a new bytecode file is written to
the appropriate augmented directory, never directly to a directory in
sys.path.


Defining augmented directories
------------------------------

Conceptually, the augmented directory for a bytecode file is the
directory in which the source file exists prefixed by the bytecode
base.  In a Unix environment this would be:

    pcb = os.path.abspath(sys.pythonbytecodebase)
    if sourcefile[0] == os.sep: sourcefile = sourcefile[1:]
    augdir = os.path.join(pcb, os.path.dirname(sourcefile))

On Windows, which does not have a single-rooted directory tree, the
drive letter of the directory containing the source file is treated as
a directory component after removing the trailing colon.  The
augmented directory is thus derived as

    pcb = os.path.abspath(sys.pythonbytecodebase)
    drive, base = os.path.splitdrive(os.path.dirname(sourcefile))
    drive = drive[:-1]
    if base[0] == "\\": base = base[1:]
    augdir = os.path.join(pcb, drive, base)

Fixing the location of the bytecode base
----------------------------------------

During program startup, the value of the PYTHONBYTECODEBASE
environment variable is made absolute, checked for validity and added
to the sys module, effectively:

    pcb = os.path.abspath(os.environ["PYTHONBYTECODEBASE"])
    try:
        probe = os.path.join(pcb, "foo")
        open(probe, "w")
        os.unlink(probe)
        sys.pythonbytecodebase = pcb
    except IOError:
        sys.pythonbytecodebase = None

This allows the user to specify the bytecode base as a relative path,
but not have it subject to changes to the current working directory.
(I can't imagine you'd want it to move around during program
execution.)

There is nothing special about sys.pythonbytecodebase.  The user may
change it at runtime if she so chooses, but normally it will not be
modified.


Rationale
=========

In many environments it is not possible for non-root users to write
into directories containing Python source files.  Most of the time,
this is not a problem as Python source is generally byte compiled
during installation.  However, there are situations where bytecode
files are either missing or need to be updated.  If the directory
containing the source file is not writable by the current user a
performance penalty is incurred each time a program importing the
module is run. [3]_ Warning messages may also be generated in certain
circumstances.  If the directory is writable, nearly simultaneous
attempts attempts to write the bytecode file by two separate processes
may occur, resulting in file corruption. [4]_

In environments with ramdisks available, it may be desirable for
performance reasons to write bytecode files to a directory on such a
disk.  Similarly, in environments where Python source code resides on
network file systems, it may be desirable to cache bytecode files on
local disks.


Alternatives
============

The only other alternative proposed so far [1]_ seems to be to add a
-R flag to the interpreter to disable writing bytecode files
altogether.  This proposal subsumes that.  Adding a command-line
option is certainly possible, but is probably not sufficient, as the
interpreter's command line is not readily available during
installation.


Issues
======

- Interpretation of a module's __file__ attribute.  I believe the
  __file__ attribute of a module should reflect the true location of
  the bytecode file.  If people want to locate a module's source code,
  they should use imp.find_module(module).

- Security - What if root has PYTHONBYTECODEBASE set?  Yes, this can
  present a security risk, but so can many other things the root user
  does.  The root user should probably not set PYTHONBYTECODEBASE
  except during installation.  Still, perhaps this problem can be
  minimized.  When running as root the interpreter should check to see
  if PYTHONBYTECODEBASE refers to a directory which is writable by
  anyone other than root.  If so, it could raise an exception or
  warning and set sys.pythonbytecodebase to None.  Or, see the next
  item.

- More security - What if PYTHONBYTECODEBASE refers to a general
  directory (say, /tmp)?  In this case, perhaps loading of a
  preexisting bytecode file should occur only if the file is owned by
  the current user or root.  (Does this matter on Windows?)


Examples
========

In the examples which follow, the urllib source code resides in
/usr/lib/python2.3/urllib.py and /usr/lib/python2.3 is in sys.path but
is not writable by the current user.

- The bytecode base is /tmp.  /usr/lib/python2.3/urllib.pyc exists and
  is valid.  When urllib is imported, the contents of
  /usr/lib/python2.3/urllib.pyc are used.  The augmented directory is
  not consulted.  No other bytecode file is generated.

- The bytecode base is /tmp.  /usr/lib/python2.3/urllib.pyc exists,
  but is out-of-date.  When urllib is imported, the generated bytecode
  file is written to urllib.pyc in the augmented directory.
  Intermediate directories will be created as needed.

- The bytecode base is None.  No urllib.pyc file is found.  When
  urllib is imported, no bytecode file is written.

- The bytecode base is /tmp.  No urllib.pyc file is found.  When
  urllib is imported, the generated bytecode file is written to the
  augmented directory, creating intermediate directories as needed.

- At startup, PYTHONBYTECODEBASE is /tmp/foobar, which does not exist.
  A warning is emitted, sys.pythonbytecodebase is set to None and no
  bytecode files are written during program execution unless
  sys.pythonbytecodebase is later changed to refer to a valid,
  writable directory.

- At startup, PYTHONBYTECODEBASE is set to /, which exists, but is not
  writable by the current user.  A warning is emitted,
  sys.pythonbytecodebase is set to None and no bytecode files are
  written during program execution unless sys.pythonbytecodebase is
  later changed to refer to a valid, writable directory.  Note that
  even though the augmented directory constructed for a particular
  bytecode file may be writable by the current user, what counts is
  that the bytecode base directory itself is writable.

- At startup PYTHONBYTECODEBASE is set to the empty string.
  sys.pythonbytecodebase is set to None.  No warning is generated,
  however.  If no urllib.pyc file is found when urllib is imported, no
  bytecode file is written.

In the Windows examples which follow, the urllib source code resides
in ``C:\PYTHON22\urllib.py``.  ``C:\\PYTHON22`` is in sys.path but is
not writable by the current user.

- The bytecode base is set to ``C:\TEMP``.  ``C:\PYTHON22\urllib.pyc``
  exists and is valid.  When urllib is imported, the contents of
  ``C:\PYTHON22\urllib.pyc`` are used.  The augmented directory is not
  consulted.

- The bytecode base is set to ``C:\TEMP``.  ``C:\PYTHON22\urllib.pyc``
  exists, but is out-of-date.  When urllib is imported, a new bytecode
  file is written to the augmented directory.  Intermediate
  directories will be created as needed.

- At startuyp PYTHONBYTECODEBASE is set to ``TEMP`` and the current
  working directory at application startup is ``H:\NET``.  The
  potential bytecode base is thus ``H:\NET\TEMP``.  If this directory
  exists and is writable by the current user, sys.pythonbytecodebase
  will be set to that value.  If not, a warning will be emitted and
  sys.pythonbytecodebase will be set to None.

- The bytecode base is ``C:\TEMP``.  No urllib.pyc file is found.
  When urllib is imported, the generated bytecode file is written to
  the augmented directory, creating intermediate directories as
  needed.

References
==========

.. [1] patch 602345, Option for not writing py.[co] files, Klose
   (http://www.python.org/sf/602345)

.. [2] python-dev thread, Disable writing .py[co], Norwitz
   (http://mail.python.org/pipermail/python-dev/2003-January/032270.html)

.. [3] Debian bug report, Mailman is writing to /usr in cron, Wegner
   (http://bugs.debian.org/cgi-bin/bugreport.cgi?bug=96111)

.. [4] python-dev thread, Parallel pyc construction, Dubois
   (http://mail.python.org/pipermail/python-dev/2003-January/032060.html)


Copyright
=========

This document has been placed in the public domain.



..
   Local Variables:
   mode: indented-text
   indent-tabs-mode: nil
   sentence-end-double-space: t
   fill-column: 70
   End: