[issue14243] tempfile.NamedTemporaryFile not particularly useful on Windows

[Paul Moore]

Paul Moore <p.f.moore at gmail.com> added the comment:

To be explicit, I'm +1 on breaking backward compatibility in the minor form described by Ethan: if NamedTemporaryFile is used as a context manager, the file is closed *on context manager exit* and *not* when the file is closed.

Breaking compatibility is allowed in minor versions (3.11 at this point, as this won't make it in before 3.10 feature freeze). So this is an acceptable change.

I don't personally think this needs a transition period or deprecation, and in particular I don't think that Jason's "gradual transition" proposal is necessary.

I'd be sad if we ended up with an over-complicated solution for no better reason than an excess of caution over a backward compatibility issue that we're not sure will impact anyone. Do we have any actual examples of code that needs the current CM behaviour (as opposed to a general concern that someone might be using the functionality)?

(My original over-complicated proposal was based on a mistaken belief that it had already been established that backward incompatibility was absolutely not allowed. But I never subscribed to that view myself.)

----------

_______________________________________
Python tracker <report at bugs.python.org>
<https://bugs.python.org/issue14243>
_______________________________________