[issue29339] Interactive: Move to same indentation level as previous line

[Terry J. Reedy]

Terry J. Reedy added the comment:

The point I was trying to get at above is that simply printing a prompt and making the use enter the entire line should work on every console, while anything fancier may not be so reliable.  Thinking more, I realize that my patch outline is incomplete. After 'line = input(prompt + indent)', line will not include the indent. A printed indent will have to be added to the input received from the user.  (In IDLE's Shell and editors, the indents that IDLE insert()s into a text widget are indistinguishable from those types by a user and *are* included in the user input that IDLE reads.)  An associated issue is that cross-platform automated tests would be difficult to impossible.

More experiment reveals the fatal problem: in REPL mode, python reads stdin and writes to stdout and stderr.  In the Windows console, and I am sure others, printed output cannot be deleted.  In particular, printed input spaces, such as the one at the end of '>>> ' cannot be deleted.  So dedenting, as in the following example, would not be possible.  One cannot input() a negative string.

if possible:
    print('I like it')
    write_patch()
    test()
else:
    print('too bad')
    reject_idea()

So unless I am wrong, the idea must be rejected.

----------
stage:  -> needs patch
versions: +Python 3.7

_______________________________________
Python tracker <report at bugs.python.org>
<http://bugs.python.org/issue29339>
_______________________________________