[issue8987] Distutils doesn't quote Windows command lines properly

[Steve Dower]

Steve Dower added the comment:

The problem is I can easily find plenty of cases where it won't work.

My biggest concern is that list2cmdline will require already-quoted arguments, which is going to break anyone who's already worked around distutils failing to do so (which makes it really difficult to justify fixing 2.7 and 3.4, and soon 3.5 unless we get it into 3.5.0). The escaping it applies for '\"' also does not take into account someone who has correctly escaped their own argument.

Particularly for distutils, we look up tools by simple name and use PATHEXT, so we may find someone's "link.bat", which then needs very different quoting from the actual "link.exe" (this one is probably unsolvable, unfortunately).

The solution isn't as simple as calling an existing function. It's probably actually as complicated as requiring callers to specify whether strings are quoted or not, and then switching between quoting modes based on what type of program (ie. EXE vs BAT) is being launched. list2cmdline is false hope here, IMO, as it just makes it harder for people to work around.

----------

_______________________________________
Python tracker <report at bugs.python.org>
<http://bugs.python.org/issue8987>
_______________________________________