[issue13062] Introspection generator and function closure state

[Nick Coghlan]

Nick Coghlan <ncoghlan at gmail.com> added the comment:

In reviewing Meador's patch (which otherwise looks pretty good), I had a thought about the functionality and signature of getclosurevars().

Currently, it equates "closure" to "nonlocal scope", which isn't really true - the function's closure is really the current binding of *all* of its free variables, and that includes globals and builtins in addition to the lexically scoped variables from outer scopes.

So what do people think about this signature:

  ClosureVars = namedtuple("ClosureVars", "nonlocals globals builtins unbound")
  def getclosurevars(func):
    """Returns a named tuple of dictionaries of the current nonlocal, global and builtin references as seen by the body of the function. A final set of unbound names is also provided."""
    # figure out nonlocal_vars (current impl)
    # figure out global_vars (try looking up names in f_globals)
    # figure out builtin_vars (try looking up names in builtins)
    # any leftover names go in unbound_vars
    return ClosureVars(nonlocal_vars, global_vars, builtin_vars, unbound_vars)

Also, something that just occurred to me is that getclosurevars() should work for already instantiated generator iterators as well as generator functions, so the current typecheck may need to be made a bit more flexible.

----------

_______________________________________
Python tracker <report at bugs.python.org>
<http://bugs.python.org/issue13062>
_______________________________________