[issue6730] dict.fromkeys() should not cross reference mutable value by default

[Georg Brandl]

Georg Brandl <georg at python.org> added the comment:

I'll add a bit of explanation as well:

> I have to add this ugly loop :
> 
> for key in keys:
>    d[key] = [] 
 
With a defaultdict, you don't -- you just use d[key], and if not already
present, the entry will be initialized with an empty list.

> I really think that :
> 1) The doc should warn about it, since it is a very weird behaviour

It is not weird in Python.  Implicit copies are never made, partly
because it's very hard to implement it correctly for every object.

> 2) There could at least be a third argument allowing the user to choose,
> with a default value that maintains the current behaviour (for
> compatibility, even though I think the default should be a deep copy)

The interface of a fundamental type like "dict" will not be changed
lightly. Usually, when a change is made, it is to add a feature that is
often requested by lots of users -- I've never seen someone request this
before.  And as we've seen, it can easily be written either using a
simple loop, or a defaultdict, depending on the exact use-case.

----------
nosy: +georg.brandl

_______________________________________
Python tracker <report at bugs.python.org>
<http://bugs.python.org/issue6730>
_______________________________________