[New-bugs-announce] [issue3688] open() rejects bytes as filename

[Dwayne Litzenberger]

New submission from Dwayne Litzenberger <dlitz at dlitz.net>:

On Linux/ext3, filenames are stored natively as sequences of octets.  On
Win32/NTFS, they are stored natively as sequences of Unicode code points.

In Python 2.x, the way to unambiguously open a particular file was to
pass the filename as a str object on Linux/ext3 and as a unicode object
on Win32/NTFS.  os.listdir(".") would return every filename as a str
object, and os.listdir(u".") would return every filename as a unicode
object---based on the current locale settings---*except* for filenames
that couldn't be decoded that way.

Consider this bash script (executed on Linux under a UTF-8 locale):

  export LC_CTYPE=en_CA.UTF-8   # requires the en_CA.UTF-8 locale to be
built
  mkdir /tmp/foo
  cd /tmp/foo
  touch $'UTF-8 compatible filename\xc2\xa2'
  touch $'UTF-8 incompatible filename\xc0'

Under Python 2.52, you get this:
  >>> import os
  >>> os.listdir(u".")
  ['UTF-8 incompatible filename\xc0', u'UTF-8 compatible filename\xa2']
  >>> os.listdir(".")
  ['UTF-8 incompatible filename\xc0', 'UTF-8 compatible filename\xc2\xa2']
  >>> [open(f, "r") for f in os.listdir(u".")]
  [<open file 'UTF-8 incompatible filename�, mode 'r' at 0xb7cee578>,
<open file 'UTF-8 compatible filename¢', mode 'r' at 0xb7cee6e0>]

Under Python 3.0b3, you get this:
  >>> import os
  >>> os.listdir(".")
  [b'UTF-8 incompatible filename\xc0', 'UTF-8 compatible filename¢']
  >>> os.listdir(b".")
  [b'UTF-8 incompatible filename\xc0', b'UTF-8 compatible filename\xc2\xa2']
  >>> [open(f, "r") for f in os.listdir(".")]
  Traceback (most recent call last):
    File "<stdin>", line 1, in <module>
    File "<stdin>", line 1, in <listcomp>
    File "/home/dwon/python3.0b3/lib/python3.0/io.py", line 284, in __new__
      return open(*args, **kwargs)
    File "/home/dwon/python3.0b3/lib/python3.0/io.py", line 184, in open
      raise TypeError("invalid file: %r" % file)
  TypeError: invalid file: b'UTF-8 incompatible filename\xc0'

This behaviour of open() makes it impossible to write code that opens
arbitrarily-named files on Linux/ext3.

----------
components: Windows
messages: 71986
nosy: dlitz
severity: normal
status: open
title: open() rejects bytes as filename
versions: Python 3.0

_______________________________________
Python tracker <report at bugs.python.org>
<http://bugs.python.org/issue3688>
_______________________________________