Reimplenting Linux Kernel in Python

[Grant Edwards]

On 2004-10-14, Carlos Ribeiro <carribeiro at gmail.com> wrote:

>>> Besides that, Linux is Posix compliant and emulates Unix
>>> system calls to a large extend, and that also makes C a
>>> natural choice.
>> 
>> Not sure I follow on that point.  Any low level language that
>> can deal with a C "struct" and byte-addressible memory would be
>> fine.
>
> Well, Unix itself was written in C,

Originally it wasn't, but recent versions are.

> and a good part of the C standard library maps naturally to
> (or at least helps to implement) functions that are mandatory
> in a Posix-compliant OS.

True, but that has nothing to do with writing a kernel.  When
working in kernel space, you don't have access to Posix
services or the standard C library.  Since you can't use the
standard C library when writing a kernel, it doesn't matter
what language it was designed for.  Likewise for any of the
Posix standards that specify the API between an application and
the system libraries.

> This does not meant that other languages cant be used; it only
> means that C is a natural choice.

I still don't see why.

> Of course, you can provide a C-like interface for a Python program
> (for example). But a OS written in pure Python would make a much
> better use of the language if it provides a Pythonic interface. I
> believe we can agree on this point, dont you think?

Not really -- the interace between the kernel and user-space
isn't particulary C-oriented.  IIRC on the x86 platform, you
make a system call by loading values into registers and
executing an interrupt instruction.  You can't even make a
Linux system call on Linux using standard C.  You have to use
assembly language wrappers that convert between the system call
API and the C API.  It would be just as easy to make those
assembly language wrappers convert to a Pascal or Python API.

-- 
Grant Edwards                   grante             Yow!  Isn't this my STOP?!
                                  at               
                               visi.com