[OT] Inuit? Eskimo?

Anton Vredegoor anton at vredegoor.doge.nl
Wed Oct 22 07:41:26 EDT 2003


Erik Max Francis <max at alcyone.com> wrote:

>I'm still not sure what you're objecting to in the bigger issue. 
>There's no question that there is an unfortunate ambiguity in the term
>_American Indian_ to mean a Native American -- which comes from
>misexpectations of the discoverers and explorers of the New World -- vs.
>an American of (Asian) Indian origin.

In my original post, which was an answer to :

>    "Native American" is to "American Indian" as ______ is to "Eskimo".

I tried to "brainstorm" some possible delicate connotations of the
terms (perhaps not so successfully), because I think that is the way
to solve analogy problems like these.

Since you cut away the problem my post was about in your first reply
to my post it's not a surprise you are now having difficulties seeing
the bigger issue, which IMO was about solving this analogy problem. 

The answer is possibly "Indian" (with ambiguous connotations)

Anton




More information about the Python-list mailing list