[issue14621] Hash function is not randomized properly

[Michal Petrucha]

Michal Petrucha <michal.petrucha at ksp.sk> added the comment:

@dmalcolm:
As for the gdb example, you need to add --eval-command="set _Py_HashSecret_Initialized=1", otherwise _Py_HashSecret will get overwritten immediately after it is set by gdb, either to 0 if run without the -R switch, or to a random value.

With the fresh pair of values Vlado provided, I managed to reproduce the collisions on Python 2.7.3, i686 (output trimmed like you did):

for __PREFIX in 0x0 0x4700 0xdead00 0xcafe00; do gdb --eval-command="break _PyRandom_Init" --eval-command="run" --eval-command="print _Py_HashSecret" --eval-command="set _Py_HashSecret.prefix=${__PREFIX}" --eval-command="set _Py_HashSecret_Initialized=1" --eval-command="print _Py_HashSecret" --eval-command="continue" -eval-command="continue" --args ./python -c "a='\x00\xcf\x0b\x96\x19'; b='\x00\x6d\x29\x45\x18'; print(hash(a)); print(hash(b))"; done

$1 = {prefix = 0, suffix = 0}
$2 = {prefix = 0, suffix = 0}
Continuing.
1220138288
1220138288


$1 = {prefix = 0, suffix = 0}
$2 = {prefix = 18176, suffix = 0}
Continuing.
-1483212240
-1483212240


$1 = {prefix = 0, suffix = 0}
$2 = {prefix = 14593280, suffix = 0}
Continuing.
-972665808
-972665808


$1 = {prefix = 0, suffix = 0}
$2 = {prefix = 13303296, suffix = 0}
Continuing.
1003122480
1003122480

----------

_______________________________________
Python tracker <report at bugs.python.org>
<http://bugs.python.org/issue14621>
_______________________________________