[issue8716] test_tk/test_tkk_guionly fails on OS X if run from buildbot slave daemon -- crashes Python

[Ned Deily]

Ned Deily <nad at acm.org> added the comment:

That's puzzling. That particular segfault failure is on test_ttk_guionly but test_tk apparently passed earlier in the run and it seems that this buildbot is being run with a window manager connection available (the changes that I added did not raise an exception and the DISPLAY env variable is set).  Further, it's an intermittent segfault.  At the moment, for this buildbot (http://www.python.org/dev/buildbot/all/buildslaves/parc-snowleopard-1), in recent builds only 2.7 builds 202 and 200 have the segfault; 2.7 builds 203 and 201 do not nor do any of the recent 3.2 or 3.x builds.  So, while the fixes I checked in do appear to prevent segfaults in the "headless" operation case (I was able to reproduce and test this on my systems), these two buildbot segfaults appear to have a different root cause.  I am going to temporarily add Ronald's suggested test for 2.7 in hopes of confirming that the window manager connection is indeed not the issue on the buildbot.  I would also be interested in confirmation that what is checked in now prevents the segfaults when running the tests under a headless ssh.

With regard to "untktests.check_tk_availability() creates a Tkinter.Button() in a subprocess. It should maybe try to create a ttk.Button() for test_ttk_guionly instead of Tkinter.Button()": ttk is not necessarily available in older versions of Tk.  The tests are structured to test for Tk availability first and then separately for ttk availability.

----------
resolution: fixed -> 
stage: committed/rejected -> test needed

_______________________________________
Python tracker <report at bugs.python.org>
<http://bugs.python.org/issue8716>
_______________________________________