[issue4707] round(25, 1) should return an integer, not a float

[David W. Lambert]

David W. Lambert <lambertdw at corning.com> added the comment:

I'd prefer round(x,positive_integer) return float.  Returning int is a 
bit of a lie, except that the decimal module is available to avoid this 
sort of lie.

For non-positive integer roundings I'd like an integer return.

In my opinion, we'd benefit from this definition of round:


import numbers

def round(a,p=0,base=10):
    '''
        >>> round(147,-1,5)
        145.0
        >>> round(143,-1,5)
        145.0
        >>> round(142,-1,5)
        140.0
        >>> round(12.345,1,2)
        12.5
        >>> round(12.345,2,2)
        12.25
        >>> round(12.345,-2,2)
        12
        >>> round(12.345,-3,2)
        16
    '''
    # consider using sign transfer for negative a

    if base < 1:
        raise ValueError('base too confusing')

    require_integral_output = (
        (p < 1) and
        isinstance(base, numbers.Integral) and
        isinstance(p, numbers.Integral))

    b = base**p
    result = int(a*b+0.5)/b
    if require_integral_output:
        result = int(0.5+result)
    return result

----------
nosy: +LambertDW

_______________________________________
Python tracker <report at bugs.python.org>
<http://bugs.python.org/issue4707>
_______________________________________