[Mailman-Users] is private mail being redirected here?

[AerosmithFanClub.com List Admin]

They are not one sided conversations.  The discussion was in reply to a 
question that I asked on the list.  IMHO it is proper to continue posting 
to the list.  In fact the undesired behavior is to take a list discussion 
private.  Questions that are asked that relate to the general topic of the 
list should stay there.  Most often if there is a question by one 
subscriber then others on the list would have the same or similar 
questions.  keeping the discussion on the list gives all subscribers 
benefit of the answer, etc.

However if the reply one is giving is one that is an ad hominem matter then 
the reply should not have been made in he first place,  It is not an issue 
of whether it belongs on the list or not.  So your beef is with the folks 
who choose not to answer a list post on the list, not with the people who 
keep posts where they belong.

Thanks...

At 04:53 AM 5/14/2002 -0400, you wrote:
 >I am seeing what appears to be a series of one-sided "answer posts" from
 >
 >  <listadmin at aerosmithfanclub.com>
 >
 >quoting messages that have not previously appeared on the mailman-users
 >list.  If this person is redirecting private responses to the list without
 >the correspondent's permission, that's considered rude Net behavior and
 >they should cease.  If there is some other technical explanation, perhaps
 >it's a Mailman issue.
 >
 >
 >------------------------------------------------------
 >Mailman-Users mailing list
 >Mailman-Users at python.org
 >http://mail.python.org/mailman/listinfo/mailman-users
 >Mailman FAQ: http://www.python.org/cgi-bin/faqw-mm.py
 >
 >
 >