[Distutils] A process for removal of PyPi entries

martin at v.loewis.de martin at v.loewis.de
Sun Jun 2 12:51:04 CEST 2013


Quoting Paul Moore <p.f.moore at gmail.com>:

> I'm -1 on anything that doesn't involve at least a minimal level of human
> involvement (possibly excepting an initial clean up exercise for projects
> with no author email)

I support this position. This is actually how PyPI has operated over the last
decade. People have always taken over projects, either the project entirely,
or just the name. It always involved contacting the original owner of  
the name.

In this thread, Lukas wrote

> Fortunately we were able to work it out with Richard
> but we had to contact him directly and waste his cycles on this.

I don't consider his cycles wasted at all. It's an important interaction.

I'm fine with formalizing the process, and I'm also fine with adding tool
support. However, I agree that a PEP should be written and agreed about this.

Personally, I'd favor this procedure:
- nothing happens unless some user explicitly requests it
- on request, the owner is contacted, and given some time to respond
- if they do respond, and are unwilling to yield the name, nothing
   happens
- if they have confirmed that they want to keep the name, they won't
   be asked again for at least one year.

Regards,
Martin





More information about the Distutils-SIG mailing list